Leverage our expertise for investment & business interests in India.
Learn more.>
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

KPPB LAW

Corporate Law Firm

  • About Us
  • Attorneys
  • Practices
    • Asset Based Lending
    • Bankruptcy Law
      • Chapter 7
      • Chapter 11
      • Purchasing Assets
      • Creditor Committee Representation
    • Business Debt Collection
    • Business Divorce
    • Commercial Loan Workouts
    • Commercial Real Estate Finance
    • Commercial Real Estate Transactions
    • Construction Law
      • Construction Project Planning
      • Construction Claims and Disputes
      • Construction Contracts
    • Contract Law
    • Corporate Governance
      • Formation of Entities
    • Cross — Border Transactions
    • DEI Strategic Counseling
    • Hotel Law
    • Immigration Law
    • India Practice
    • Intellectual Property
    • Investment Management
    • Labor & Employment Law
      • Employment Litigation
    • Landlord/Tenant Law
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Securities
    • Tax Law
    • Technology Law
    • Trusts & Estates
  • Firm News
  • Legal Blog
  • 1-678-443-2244
  • Contact Us

Contract Disputes · September 19, 2022 · by Roy Banerjee

Can An Employer Make An Employee Sign An Arbitration Agreement?

Home › Contract Disputes › Can An Employer Make An Employee Sign An Arbitration Agreement?

Contract Disputes · September 19, 2022 · by Roy Banerjee

boss yelling at employee for missing deadlineWhen conflict arises between you and your employee, legal protection can be a valuable asset in case they decide to file a suit against your business. A civil lawsuit and the related court costs can be time-consuming and expensive, which has led to the growing popularity of arbitration agreements for business owners.

Here is what you need to know about how an employer navigates their responsibilities and obligations in the context of arbitration.

What Is an Arbitration Agreement?

An arbitration agreement is a method that allows a conflict to be resolved outside of court. While many types of disagreements can be taken to court where each party shares their side of events and a judge or jury decides the outcome, arbitration allows for the involved parties to collaborate toward a conclusion.

In the agreement, each party surrenders the right to litigate or go to court. When parties are bound by an arbitration agreement, they consent to keep their disagreement out of litigation and resolve it strictly through arbitration. The arbitration process usually removes some advantages of litigation, such as the ability to appeal a decision. It also provides some benefits, including greater affordability and confidentiality.

Arbitration is a private event; an arbitrator replaces the judge, and the arbitrator may be chosen by one of the involved parties depending on the verbiage of the agreement. There is no jury; the arbitrator will make the sole decision in the disagreement. Both sides still present evidence as they would in a courtroom, but the rules are more relaxed.

It is worthwhile to remember that although arbitration is private that does not mean relevant incidents cannot be reported to authorities. Arbitration agreements do not remove an employee’s rights. If the conflict arose out of discriminatory or improper treatment, the employee may still contact OSHA, the Equal Opportunity Commission, or other organizations to report violations.

Can You Make an Employee Sign an Arbitration Agreement?

international arbitration mediation courtIn the United States, most employees are employed in at-will states. This means they may be fired or a job can be rescinded for any reason, including an employee’s unwillingness to sign all of the proper contracts and consent forms required to do the job.

An employer cannot force an employee to sign an arbitration agreement for the same reason that the employee cannot compel their employer to do so: it must be signed willingly. However, in at-will states, this means that the employer may terminate the worker’s employment (or potential employment) for failing to sign the agreement.

There are exceptions to this rule. If the employee had previously signed a contract stipulating reasons for which they may be fired, and the employer later introduced an arbitration agreement the employee may only be fired if failure to sign the agreement is contained within the language of the initially signed contract. However, some states do not allow employer-employee arbitration agreements, and some employer-employee relationships do not allow for arbitration.

An employee may attempt to negotiate the terms of the agreement if their issue with signing is relevant to the specific details and not the concept of the arbitration itself. It is always advisable to speak with an attorney before creating an arbitration agreement for your employees.

There are also some circumstances in which an arbitration agreement is considered non-enforceable. This is the primary reason why any employer should work closely with a legal professional to create an arbitration agreement rather than writing one on their own. In many states, if an arbitration contract is considered to be “procedurally unconscionable” or “substantively unconscionable,” it may not be eligible for enforcement, even if the employee did agree to sign the agreement.

Something being “unconscionable” in an arbitration agreement usually has the appearance of forcing the employee to experience undue hardship or an unfair outcome. For example, an arbitration agreement might stipulate that the arbitrator will be a specific company (Arbitrator A).

However, upon further inspection, Arbitrator A works for and is paid by the company with whom the employee has the disagreement. If the employee discovers that the arbitrator negotiating the case is paid by the employer, this may constitute bias and may not provide a fair opportunity for both sides to be heard. This may qualify as “procedural” unconscionability.

Similarly, the consequences of the arbitration cannot be unduly harsh. If an employer is arbitrating against an employee and is seeking the life savings and house of the employee as recompense, the employer may be considered to be behaving with “substantively unconscionable” actions.

An employer is required to take certain steps when asking employees to sign an arbitration agreement, to ensure that it is fair. These include guaranteeing that the potential compensation is similar to what the parties would be able to achieve in court and that discovery lasts a reasonable amount of time allowing all parties the chance to adequately prepare their case.

The Risks of Arbitration Agreements

arbitration agreement with penResolving conflicts outside of the courtroom has benefits including lower costs, but some agreements are not always advantageous.

Since arbitration is a private matter (whereas lawsuits are public), an employee cannot benefit from the precedent of another employee’s arbitration. When presenting a case in court, the court will look at how previous cases were resolved for guidance on rulings; however, an arbitrator works independently of any previous conflicts. If previous employees succeeded in their arbitration efforts against an employer, that will have no impact on the current case.

It is also important to understand that in arbitration, the decision is final. Neither party can challenge the amount of compensation or type of recompense that they are awarded. There are very few opportunities for appeals as would be available in a lawsuit.

Appeals usually only arise due to an arbitrator’s gross negligence or fraud which can be difficult to prove. If either party wants a specific outcome or dollar amount, they can make this known during their arguments, but it is the arbitrator’s decision to determine what is both fair and reasonable.

Arbitrators may be deemed negligent (and thus liable for legal action) if they fail to disclose information that would indicate their partiality, if they intentionally prolong the resolution of a case or if they refuse to review substantial evidence. Failure to do so may mean that the case will transfer to a new arbitrator, after which the original, negligent arbitrator may be legally pursued in a separate case.

An arbitrator must equally evaluate all of the information in a case and provide a fair and unbiased decision for the two parties. It is generally the employer who is responsible for the costs associated with the arbitration (such as the arbitrator’s fees) making this method of conflict resolution available to all employees regardless of financial status.

The Potential Benefits of Arbitration

arbitration pool balls conceptWhile arbitration does have some negatives, it can offer advantages over the courtroom in the right circumstances. Arbitration is not inherently negative or a less than ideal outcome.
Resolutions tend to come more quickly through arbitration than through litigation.

There is no requirement to wait for a court date, which by itself can take months or years to schedule. The period for discovery is also shorter in arbitration. The discovery phase alone is one of the leading factors that contribute to the excessive duration of a court case. A thorough discovery process can take months. In arbitration, discovery concludes much sooner, and because arbitration cannot be appealed, a process that can last years, you can rest assured that the case will have a final resolution far more quickly.

Discovery is a process, for court and arbitration, during which all relevant evidence is collected and presented to the judge or arbitrator. A larger employer has more opportunity to collect information and create a case than a single employee does because the employer has more time, money, and reach to gather information.

A single employee may spend a significant amount of their free time gathering documents, printing them, and getting in touch with people who have access to the information they need.

Those people may need to get permission to share the information or acquire the materials needed. Compare this to an employer, who may have direct access to the information they need and can pay for official copies or even related professional services (like private investigation) if necessary.

Trust the Professionals to Help You Navigate Arbitration Agreements in the Workplace

Whether you need assistance with an existing workplace conflict or need a professional to review the language of your arbitration agreement, trust the experts. The attorneys at KPPB LAW will gladly help you understand the process of arbitration. Contact our experienced team to learn more or schedule a consultation.

Filed Under: Contract Disputes

Roy Banerjee profile picture
Roy Banerjee

Roy Banerjee helps defend, settle and pursue claims to protect your business interests. He is an accomplished business litigator who specializes in efficient resolution of real estate and business matters.

About KPPB LAW

KPPB LAW is one of the largest South-Asian owned business law firms in the United States, and a minority-owned enterprise certified by the National Minority Supplier Development Council. Our law firm is AV-rated by Martindale Hubbell and a member of the National Association of Minority and Women Owned Law Firms. Founded in 2003 by 4 South-Asian lawyers, Sonjui Kumar, Kirtan Patel, Roy Banerjee, and Nick Prabhu, Atlanta-based KPPB LAW today includes 21 attorneys in 5 states and focuses on supporting the legal needs of businesses of all sizes across all industries and offers strong expertise for global businesses with business interests in India. For more information, visit kppblaw.com or talk to one of our business attorneys at 678-443-2220.

Articles published by KPPB LAW are purely for educational purposes and provide generalized information of the topic(s) covered. These articles should not be considered as legal advice. Please contact the attorneys at KPPB LAW to have a conversation about your specific legal matter.

Primary Sidebar

Ready to speak with an attorney?

Call Now!

Contact Us

Use the form below. We will review your message and respond in a timely manner.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

info@kppblaw.com


Footer

GEORGIA

[Corporate Office]
One Lakeside Commons
Suite 800
990 Hammond Drive
Atlanta, GA 30328
678.443.2220
View Map

NEW YORK

575 Fifth Avenue, Suite 1400
New York, NY 10017
203.875.0808
View Map

CONNECTICUT

470 James Street
New Haven, Connecticut 06513
203.800.7417
View Map

+
161 Kings Hwy E / First Floor
Fairfield, Connecticut 06825
203.576.9211
View Map

VIRGINIA

7330 Heritage Village Plaza
Suite 201
Gainesville, Virginia 20155
571.248.2566
View Map

ILLINOIS

Chicago
312.857.5264
View Map

© 2025 KPPB LAW · All Rights Reserved · Legal Disclaimer

Website powered by 321 Web Marketing

We and the third parties that provide content, functionality, or business services on our website may use cookies to collect information about your browsing activities in order to provide you with more relevant content and promotional materials, on and off the website, and help us understand your interests and improve the website.Ok